Why the pain?

Embraced by the Needle
by Dr. Gabor Mate

Addictions always originate in unhappiness, even if hidden.

They are emotional anesthetics; they numb pain.  The first question — always — is not “Why the addiction?” but “Why the pain?” The answer, ever the same, is scrawled with crude eloquence on the wall of my patient Anna’s room at the Portland Hotel in the heart of Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside: “Any place I went to, I wasn’t wanted. And that bites large.”

The Downtown Eastside is considered to be Canada’s drug capital, with an addict population of 3,000 to 5,000 individuals.  I am staff physician at the Portland, a non-profit, harm-reduction facility where most of the clients are addicted to cocaine, to alcohol, to opiates like heroin, or to tranquilizers — or to any combination of these things.

Many also suffer from mental illness.

Like Anna, a 32-year-old poet, many are HIV positive or have full-blown AIDS.  The methadone I prescribe for their opiate dependence does little for the emotional anguish compressed in every heartbeat of these driven souls.

Methadone staves off the torment of opiate withdrawal, but, unlike heroin, it does not create a “high” for regular users.

The essence of that high was best expressed by a 27-year-old sex-trade worker.  “The first time I did heroin,” she said, “it felt like a warm, soft hug.” In a phrase, she summed up the psychological and chemical cravings that make some people vulnerable to substance dependence.

No drug is, in itself, addictive.

Only about 8 per cent to 15 per cent of people who try, say alcohol or marijuana, go on to addictive use.  What makes them vulnerable? Neither physiological predispositions nor individual moral failures explain drug addictions.  Chemical and emotional vulnerability are the products of life experience, according to current brain research and developmental psychology.

Most human-brain growth occurs following birth; physical and emotional interactions determine much of our brain development.  Each brain’s circuitry and chemistry reflects individual life experiences as much as inherited tendencies.

For any drug to work in the brain, the nerve cells have to have receptors – — sites where the drug can bind.  We have opiate receptors because our brain has natural opiate-like substances, called endorphins, chemicals that participate in many functions, including the regulation of pain and mood.  Similarly, tranquilizers of the benzodiazepine class, such as Valium, exert their effect at the brain’s natural benzodiazepine receptors.

Infant rats who get less grooming from their mothers have fewer natural benzo receptors in the part of the brain that controls anxiety.

Brains of infant monkeys separated from their mothers for only a few days are measurably deficient in the key neurochemical, dopamine.

It is the same with human beings.

Endorphins are released in the infant’s brain when there are warm, non-stressed, calm interactions with the parenting figures.

Endorphins, in turn, promote the growth of receptors and nerve cells, and the discharge of other important brain chemicals.  The fewer endorphin-enhancing experiences in infancy and early childhood, the greater the need for external sources.

Hence, the greater vulnerability to addictions.

Distinguishing skid row addicts is the extreme degree of stress they had to endure early in life.  Almost all women now inhabiting Canada’s addiction capital suffered sexual assaults in childhood, as did many of the males.

Childhood memories of serial abandonment or severe physical and psychological abuse are common.  The histories of my Portland patients tell of pain upon pain.

Carl, a 36-year-old native, was banished from one foster home after another, had dishwashing liquid poured down his throat for using foul language at age 5, and was tied to a chair in a dark room to control his hyperactivity.  When angry at himself — as he was recently, for using cocaine — he gouges his foot with a knife as punishment.  His facial expression was that of a terrorized urchin who had just broken some family law and feared draconian retribution.  I reassured him I wasn’t his foster parent, and that he didn’t owe it to me not to screw up.

But what of families where there was not abuse, but love, where parents did their best to provide their children with a secure, nurturing home? One also sees addictions arising in such families.  The unseen factor here is the stress the parents themselves lived under, even if they did not recognize it.  That stress could come from relationship problems, or from outside circumstances such as economic pressure or political disruption.  The most frequent source of hidden stress is the parents’ own childhood histories that saddled them with emotional baggage they had never become conscious of.  What we are not aware of in ourselves, we pass on to our children.

Stressed, anxious, or depressed parents have great difficulty initiating enough of those emotionally rewarding, endorphin-liberating interactions with their children.

Later in life such children may experience a hit of heroin as the “warm, soft hug” my patient described: What they didn’t get enough of before, they can now inject.

Feeling alone, feeling there has never been anyone with whom to share their deepest emotions, is universal among drug addicts.

That is what Anna had lamented on her wall.  No matter how much love a parent has, the child does not experience being wanted unless he or she is made absolutely safe to express exactly how unhappy, or angry, or hate-filled he or she may at times feel.  The sense of unconditional love, of being fully accepted even when most ornery, is what no addict ever experienced in childhood — often not because the parents did not have it to give, simply because they did not know how to transmit it to the child.

Addicts rarely make the connection between troubled childhood experiences and self-harming habits.

They blame themselves — and that is the greatest wound of all, being cut off from their natural self-compassion.  “I was hit a lot,” 40-year-old Wayne says, “but I asked for it.  Then I made some stupid decisions.” And would he hit a child, no matter how much that child “asked for it”? Would he blame that child for “stupid decisions”?

Wayne looks away.  “I don’t want to talk about that crap,” says this tough man, who has worked on oil rigs and construction sites and served 15 years in jail for robbery.

He looks away and wipes tears from his eyes.

Source: http://drgabormate.com/embraced-by-the-needle/#more-244′


~ by Brendan Kober on January 24, 2012.

One Response to “Why the pain?”

  1. 1. Drugs don’t just numb they also cause pleasure.
    2. Heroin taken regularly at the same dose just like methadone and all other opiates does not cause a “high”, that’s tolerance. The difference between methadone and heroin is that methadone requires once daily dosing while heroin needs to be taken 4-6 times a day. In addition heroin is not very well absorbed taken orally while methadone is and oral dosing is generally preferred.
    3. Many drugs are inherently addictive. The fact that some people have more vulnerability to those drugs doesn’t change that.
    4. Trying to blame “stress” for addiction (when you don’t blame outright abuse) makes no sense given that all people experience significant stress as they grow up over their childhoods and all peoples parents suffer various kinds of stresses. Most of those people do not end up as addicts.

    I dunno if I am an addict but there is a fair chance that by societies standards I am (case in point, I am on subutex to detox from opiate dependency, a detox, not maintenance and I have completely fucked it up, took heroin, took too much of my subutex causing me not to have enough later, took a bunch of benzos when I wasn’t meant to and don’t even enjoy them…).

    I had no worse a childhood than anyone else. Drug use is not all about oblivion and escaping pain (sometimes that is a part of it, a lot of the time it isn’t). The truth is, when I take opiates I find that they do the opposite of hiding me from pain, they give me the courage and confidence and capacity to face up to pain and understand it better and learn from it. The whole trying to blame addiction on shitty stuff that happened in the past always annoyed me. Life sucks, everyone has to deal with that, only a few people become compulsively involved in consuming pleasure inducing chemicals.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s